Skip to Main Content

Hurricane Helene Took a Toll on Virginia’s Eastern Hellbender Populations

By Molly Kirk/DWR

Photos by Photo by Holly Funkhouser/VA Tec

Some of the wildlife most impacted by Hurricane Helene in September 2024 are some of the least visible—the eastern hellbenders. While the game fish populations seem to have weathered the storm with minimal detrimental effects, eastern hellbenders appear to have suffered greater impacts, as far as biologists can tell at this point.

DWR’s State Herpetologist, J.D. Kleopfer, has spoken with Dr. William A. Hopkins, a professor at Virginia Tech who is working with Kleopfer on hellbender conservation and has assessed some of the damage to hellbender habitats. “He told me that there were sections of streams that were only a couple feet deep that are now six feet deep. There are massive boulder moved, and others are buried. He said some prior sections of stream channels are completely gone; they’ve just completely changed their course,” Kleopfer said. Portions of the Clinch and Holston watersheds in southwest Virginia were among the most impacted by Helene, and they’re also where Virginia’s hellbender populations primarily exist.

A photo of a stream with a large expanse of exposed rock to one side, with a man standing on the rocks with a small square of concrete by his feet.

The stream channel completely moved along many stream reaches. The cobble showing on the right of the photo is all newly deposited rock–this area of the river used to be about two feet deep. The lid from a last hellbender nest box is on the ground by the person’s right foot. 

 

Even before Helene, conservation work had been underway for the eastern hellbender populations in the Holston and Clinch river watersheds in Virginia. Hellbenders are listed as Tier 1a (Critical Conservation Need with “immediate and intense management action” required to prevent extinction) species of Greatest Conservation Need in the Virginia Wildlife Action Plan, and in December 2024, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) submitted a proposal to list the eastern hellbender as federally endangered. Threats to hellbenders include loss of forest buffers along streams and rivers and human interference with their nesting sites, which are under large, flat rocks on the riverbed floor. Hellbender nesting season begins in late August and early September; the male hellbender guards a nest that contains hundreds of eggs under a rock until they hatch in April.

For the last decade, DWR and Virginia Tech have been working together on building and placing artificial nest boxes on the bottom of the rivers —large concrete boxes that mimic the under-rock space that hellbenders use for nesting. The boxes provide hellbenders with high-quality nesting sites that aren’t affected by human disturbance of the river bottom and allow researchers to more easily monitor and study their reproductive output.

Kleopfer noted that he and the Virginia Tech researchers had identified and were monitoring 58 nests in early September 2024. “We were having our best nesting year so far,” he said. “But in the hardest-hit streams, most nests were probably wiped out because the hurricane hit right after breeding season. If there were eggs in those boxes, they may have been washed out by the river flow, and the adult hellbenders could have been trapped in boxes or on the river bottom by massive layers of sediment, cobble, and boulder.” Hellbenders in natural nesting sites would have been affected just as well, as heavy river flow would have washed out the site, and possibly washed the adults miles downstream or buried them alive. Numerous verified reports from concerned citizens also showed the flood actually washed adult hellbenders onto land.

A photo of a square of concrete at the edge of a stream with rocks on top of it.

A hellbender nest box completely packed with rock and sediment and almost out of the water because the stream channel moved. This box was once a couple feet under water during low flow.

A photo of an eastern hellbender underwater in a square, concrete box.

A trapped, live hellbender covered in sediment that Virginia Tech researchers saved.

“This is going to be one of those evolutionary events that occurs in the history of the species that will need decades upon decades of recovery,” Kleopfer said. “It may be 100 years before these populations recover. This is a long-lived species —they potentially live more than 30 years in the wild and take about seven years to reach reproductive age—so their abilities to recover are pretty slow. If you turn back the clock just 500 years, recovery wouldn’t have been that challenging because the landscape was so much more intact and less impacted by human footprint. But now, they have to not only deal with the recovery from this storm, but they have to do it in the context of what the landscape looks like now, which is just going to slow it down even more. I’m hopeful that they’ll recover, but it’s going to be a long time.”

Luckily, Kleopfer and Hopkins have the nesting box technology and strategies already in place to be able to begin restoration efforts before the 2025 nesting season. In addition, Hopkins and his team at Virginia Tech were awarded a $2-million-dollar grant from the National Science Foundation and the Paul G. Allen Family Foundation for hellbender conservation work. “This grant will really allow us to implement some real on-the-ground conservation actions and hopefully move the needle on recovery for this species,” Kleopfer said.

The grant focuses on research into another population threat for eastern hellbenders—a bizarre behavior known as “filial cannibalism.” This is when the male hellbenders actually consume the eggs they’re guarding. “We don’t know why,” Kleopfer said. “There’s plenty of food out there for them and all their body conditions are in great shape. They seem healthy. So, we think it might have to do with dissolved oxygen levels or something else related to water chemistry that affects their behavior. The grant work will try to untangle all of this and find a solution.”

One solution is to take fertilized eggs, hatch them out in the Fralin Life Sciences Institute lab at Virginia Tech, and then re-introduce the hellbender larvae back into the nest boxes and protect them so the adult male can’t eat them. “Hopefully, that will allow for these animals to develop and start to grow into adults, and jump-start the populations,” Kleopfer said. “This will complement efforts that are going on in stream restoration—creating more vegetative buffer and forest along these streams. Removing that vegetative buffer along these streams creates a whole suite of problems, from sediment runoff to declines in dissolved oxygen levels, and changes in the macro fauna, so there’s a whole cascade of events that affects all of the animals in the streams, including trout and declining populations like mussels and hellbenders. There’s a lot of conservation efforts going on out there to restore these riparian corridors. While that’s going on, we want to augment these populations to boost them along until they start to recover. Hopefully, in the meantime, we can also identify exactly what is causing this phenomenon.”

It will take some time for Kleopfer and the Virginia Tech researchers to fully understand Helene’s impact on the hellbender populations of the Clinch and Holston watersheds, but come spring, they’ll be out in the waters collecting data and making a plan to help ensure that the 2025 nesting season, and those further into the future, are as productive as possible.

Click here for our visitor's guide to DWR properties for all the info you need to make sure your adventure is a successful one.
  • January 13, 2025